An Official Pennsylvania Government Website
  •  

April 14, 2021 - Lehighton, PA

Pennsylvania State Police Discuss Carbon County Cold Case Arrest

On December 20, 1976, the Pennsylvania State Police (PSP) was contacted to investigate human remains found on the bank of the Lehigh River in East Side Borough, Carbon County, Pennsylvania. The investigation revealed two sets of unidentified remains - a young female and near full-term fetus.

After more than 44 years and thanks to advances in DNA technology, the female remains were recently identified as Evelyn Colon of Jersey City, New Jersey. Evelyn was 15 years old in 1976. Armed with this important new information, investigators from PSP Troop N reviewed the case and developed a suspect.

On March 31, 2021, one count of criminal homicide was filed against Luis Sierra, 63, of Ozone Park, NY. Sierra, who was 19 years old in 1976 and in a romantic relationship with the victim, was taken into custody by officials in New York and recently extradited to Pennsylvania. Charging documents were filed in Magisterial District Court 56-3-01 in Carbon County.

On Wednesday, April 14, 2021, members of the Pennsylvania State Police were joined by the Carbon County District Attorney to discuss the latest developments in the case. Speakers included:
- Trooper Anthony Petroski, Public Information Officer, Pennsylvania State Police Troop N
- Lieutenant Devon Brutosky, Commander, Pennsylvania State Police Troop N Criminal Investigation Section
- Michael Greek, Carbon County District Attorney


Lieutenant Devon Brutosky, Commander of the Pennsylvania State Police Troop N Criminal Investigation, addresses the media with new developments about a 1976 cold case investigation. Lehighton, PA on April 14, 2021. <br><a href="https://filesource.amperwave.net/commonwealthofpa/photo/18678_psp_coldcase_01.jpg" target="_blank">⇣ Download Photo</a> Lieutenant Devon Brutosky (left) and Trooper Anthony Petroski (right) provide updates on a 1976 cold case investigation in Lehighton, PA on April 14, 2021. <br><a href="https://filesource.amperwave.net/commonwealthofpa/photo/18678_psp_coldcase_02.jpg" target="_blank">⇣ Download Photo</a> Trooper Anthony Petroski, Public Information Officer for the Pennsylvania State Police, discusses details of a 1976 cold case, including the arrest of Luis Sierra, 63, of Ozone Park, NY. Lehighton, PA on April 14, 2021. <br><a href="https://filesource.amperwave.net/commonwealthofpa/photo/18678_psp_coldcase_03.jpg" target="_blank">⇣ Download Photo</a> Trooper Anthony Petroski, Public Information Officer for the Pennsylvania State Police, discusses details of a 1976 cold case, including the arrest of Luis Sierra, 63, of Ozone Park, NY. Lehighton, PA on April 14, 2021. <br><a href="https://filesource.amperwave.net/commonwealthofpa/photo/18678_psp_coldcase_04.jpg" target="_blank">⇣ Download Photo</a> The investigation into the murder of Evelyn Colon is ongoing. Anyone with information related to the case can contact Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers.  Lehighton, PA on April 14, 2021. <br><a href="https://filesource.amperwave.net/commonwealthofpa/photo/18678_psp_coldcase_05.jpg" target="_blank">⇣ Download Photo</a> Lieutenant Devon Brutosky outlines details of the investigation, but reminds the public that the investigation is ongoing and to contact the Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers with any additional information. Lehighton, PA on April 14, 2021. <br><a href="https://filesource.amperwave.net/commonwealthofpa/photo/18678_psp_coldcase_06.jpg" target="_blank">⇣ Download Photo</a> Pennsylvania State Police and the Carbon County District Attorneys Office were accompanied by members of the investigation, past and present, to discuss the latest developments in the case. Lehighton, PA on April 14, 2021. <br><a href="https://filesource.amperwave.net/commonwealthofpa/photo/18678_psp_coldcase_07.jpg" target="_blank">⇣ Download Photo</a> Michael Greek, Carbon County District Attorney, discusses the legal process for the case and how many laws have changed since 1976, in Lehighton, PA on April 14, 2021. <br><a href="https://filesource.amperwave.net/commonwealthofpa/photo/18678_psp_coldcase_08.jpg" target="_blank">⇣ Download Photo</a> Michael Greek, Carbon County District Attorney, discusses the legal process for the case and how many laws have changed since 1976, in Lehighton, PA on April 14, 2021. <br><a href="https://filesource.amperwave.net/commonwealthofpa/photo/18678_psp_coldcase_09.jpg" target="_blank">⇣ Download Photo</a> Pennsylvania State Police and the Carbon County District Attorneys Office were accompanied by members of the investigation, past and present, to discuss the latest developments in the case. Lehighton, PA on April 14, 2021. <br><a href="https://filesource.amperwave.net/commonwealthofpa/photo/18678_psp_coldcase_10.jpg" target="_blank">⇣ Download Photo</a> Lieutenant Devon Brutosky outlines details of the investigation, but reminds the public that the investigation is ongoing and to contact the Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers with any additional information. Lehighton, PA on April 14, 2021. <br><a href="https://filesource.amperwave.net/commonwealthofpa/photo/18678_psp_coldcase_11.jpg" target="_blank">⇣ Download Photo</a> Evelyn Colon of Jersey City, NJ was 15 years old and 9 months pregnant when she was last seen in 1976. After more than 44 years, female remains found on the banks of the Lehigh River on December 20, 1976, were identified as Evelyn Colon. Lehighton, PA on April 14, 2021. <br><a href="https://filesource.amperwave.net/commonwealthofpa/photo/18678_psp_coldcase_12.jpg" target="_blank">⇣ Download Photo</a> Trooper Anthony Petroski (right) and Lieutenant Devon Brutosky (left) provide updates on a 1976 cold case investigation in Lehighton, PA on April 14, 2021. <br><a href="https://filesource.amperwave.net/commonwealthofpa/photo/18678_psp_coldcase_13.jpg" target="_blank">⇣ Download Photo</a> Evelyn Colon of Jersey City, NJ was 15 years old and 9 months pregnant when she was last seen in 1976. After more than 44 years, female remains found on the banks of the Lehigh River on December 20, 1976, were identified as Evelyn Colon. Lehighton, PA on April 14, 2021. <br><a href="https://filesource.amperwave.net/commonwealthofpa/photo/18678_psp_coldcase_14.jpg" target="_blank">⇣ Download Photo</a>